Summary

Yosef Karo Shulchan Aruch — 50 General laws about punctured body parts

And all that we said that if it's removed it's treif, it's the same rule if it's created missing it, but there are some who rule this kosher.
(o.o.) (And if it's a big loss it's you can rely on those who rule it kosher) . 3 Any body part that invalidates it if it's punctured or missing or removed, if it's decomposed it invalidates it too.
Rema: But for us who are not expert - whenever the flesh is altered to a fault, it should be considered as a puncture there (H"M and Mord') .
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature