by John Marshall, Royal Naval Biography — Laugharne… (1823)
“ His “conspicuous gallantry” in bearing down upon the enemy, “entitled him,” says Mr. James, “to a better ship than the Alert, a better first lieutenant than Andrew Duncan, who gave him no support, and a better crew than his officers and men, who, except Johanson Clering, the master, and William Haggerty, the purser, went aft to request him to strike the colours. Captain Porter (of the Essex) disarmed his fine prize, and sent her, with the prisoners, as a cartel, to Newfoundland; where, on the 8th Oct., Commander Laugharne and his officers and men were tried for the loss of their ship. ”
