Morrison Waite

“ The district court was not bound to surrender its jurisdiction until a case was made which on the face of the record showed that the petitioners were in law entitled to a removal. The mere filing of a petition is not enough, unless, when taken in connection with the rest of the record, it shows on its face that the petitioner has, under the statute, the right to take the suit to another tribunal. ”

“ On the twenty-seventh of September, 1880, Lavender, Phillpot, and Cantlon filed their answer to the cross-petition of Hartley. On the fifth of November, 1880, leave was given Parshall and Tingley to file amended answers in 40 days, and on the thirteenth of December, 1880, Parshall did file his answer and cross-petition, claiming to be the owner of Kellogg's note to Lavender falling due in 1874, and asking to enforce a lien on the property for its payment. ”

“ Five terms of the court had passed, at either one of which the case would have been triable if the parties had taken the usual steps as to pleadings and preparations. In fact, more than a year had elapsed from the time the issues had actually been made up on the pleadings of some of the parties. ”