Moulavi Gerágh Ali

“ The ascription of Ibn Omar's (died 73 A.H.) story, not strictly to the point, is untrustworthy. Abu Hurera's narration is also admitted as apocryphal; vide Dur-rul-mansoor, by Soyutí. All these traditions are noted by Soyutí in his Dur-rul-mansoor. The tradition by Nasáee (died 303 A.H.) from Anas (died 90 A.H.) regarding the affair of a slave is equally contradicted by the tradition from Ayesha, the widow of the Prophet, narrated by the traditionist Nasáee in the same place of his collection of traditions. This is the story of the honey. vide para. 16, ubi supra. ”