Summary

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Dillon v. Barnard — Opinion of the Court

Such expectation, however reasonable, founded even upon the express promise of the employer that the funds shall be thus devoted, of itself avails nothing in favor of the contractor. Before there can arise any lien on the funds of the employer, there must be, in addition to such express promise, upon which the contractor relies, some act of appropriation on the part of the employer depriving himself of the control of the funds, and conferring upon the contractor the right to have them applied to his payment when the services are rendered or the materials are furnished.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Dillon v. Barnard — Opinion of the Court

The contractors are not parties to the indenture, and are not entitled to claim as against those parties any benefit under its provisions, except that upon the assent being given to their contracts the use of the moneys for their payment is permissible. They are, so far as the agreement is concerned, strangers to the instrument. The written assent to contracts on the part of one of the trustees, was not required for their protection, but as an additional safeguard to the bondholders against an improvident use of the funds by the corporation.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Dillon v. Barnard — Opinion of the Court

The positions thus asserted must find their support, if at all, in the provisions of the indenture of mortgage. If not sustained there they are not sustained anywhere. The averments of the bill as to the purport and meaning of the provisions of the indenture, the object of their insertion in the instrument, and the obligations they imposed upon the corporation and the trustees, and the rights they conferred upon the plaintiff when his contract was approved, are not admitted by the demurrer.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature