Summary

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Settlemier v. Sullivan — Opinion of the Court

We do not question the doctrine that a court of general jurisdiction acting within the scope of its authority-that is, within the boundaries which the law assigns to it with respect to subjects and persons-is presumed to act rightly and to have jurisdiction to render the judgment it pronounces, until the contrary appears. But this presumption can only arise with respect to jurisdictional facts, concerning which the record is silent. It cannot be indulged when the evidence respecting the facts is stated, or averments respecting them are made.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Settlemier v. Sullivan — Opinion of the Court

If the certificate of the sheriff were the only document in the record referring to the service of the complaint and notice, there would be no doubt as to the correctness of the ruling of the court below. Service upon the wife of the defendant was not service upon him. No theoretical unity of husband and wife can make service upon one equivalent to service upon the other. Personal citation to the defendant, or his voluntary appearance, is the essential preliminary to a purely personal judgment.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Settlemier v. Sullivan — Opinion of the Court

Page (18 Wall. 366) , 'it appears from the return of the officer or the proof of service contained in the record that the summons was served at a particular place, and there is no averment of any other service, it will not be presumed that service was also made at another and different place; or if it appear in like manner that the service was made upon a person other than the defendant, it will not be presumed, in the silence of the record, that it was made upon the defendant also.'
We are of opinion that the principle here stated applies in this case.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature