Summary

Portrait of Harold Hitz Burton Harold Hitz Burton Isbrandtsen Company v. Johnson…

From this, we conclude that Congress has preempted the area relating to deductions and set-offs based upon derelictions of duty as against a seaman's claim to his wages. Congress has gone so far in expressly listing such deductions and set-offs that it is a fair inference that those not listed may not be made. It thus remains for the courts to determine only what are the deductions or set-offs for derelictions of duty that are listed by Congress, rather than to determine which of the deductions or set-offs once known to the general maritime law Congress has failed to exclude.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Harold Hitz Burton Harold Hitz Burton Isbrandtsen Company v. Johnson…

Congressional legislation now touches nearly every phase of a seaman's life. It concerns itself with his personal safety, comfort and health in many ways not necessary to review here. It deals specifically with his shipping articles and the payment to him of his wages. It insures generally a partial payment to him of his wages at each port where his vessel loads or delivers cargo. It insures the payment to him of the balance of those wages upon completion of his voyage or shortly after his discharge. [6] It deals explicitly with the final payment of wages.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Harold Hitz Burton Harold Hitz Burton Isbrandtsen Company v. Johnson…

Such an assault may lead to imprisonment of the offender but it entails no 'forfeiture.' If no 'forfeiture' may be set off against a seaman's wages for expenses resulting to his employer from his assault upon a superior officer, there is little basis to imply congressional approval of a set-off against his wages to cover expenses resulting from his assault upon a fellow member of the crew not his superior.↑ For comparable reasons, petitioner's counterclaim may not be set off against the allowance made to respondent for transportation to his port of signing on.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature