Summary

Harper's Weekly Harper's Weekly Editorials on Carl Schurz…

When criminals and scoundrels have provoked an Indian rising, those officers are called to suppress it. Why not authorize them to prevent it? Place the Indians upon reservations, scrupulously observe the conditions that we impose, keep the white settlers off as sternly as the Indians are kept in, punish white and red offenders promptly, and equally, feed and clothe the Indians faithfully, cut off from them gunpowder and whiskey by summary suppression of the traffic in both, and the beginning of civilization will be possible.
Source: Wikisource

Harper's Weekly Harper's Weekly Editorials on Carl Schurz…

But we can not resist the conviction that the character of the officers of the army offers a much better guarantee of the prompt correction of the abuses of which the Indians justly complain, than the character of Indian traders and agents and dealers of every kind. Granting the strongest allegation that can be made, that the Indian troubles spring from the cheating and outrage and wanton injustice of the whites, official and unofficial, with whom the Indians come in contact, the question is whether officers of the army would be guilty of such cheating, outrage, and injustice.
Source: Wikisource

Harper's Weekly Harper's Weekly Editorials on Carl Schurz…

Those who agree with the Secretary that the great object of the Indian policy must be the ultimate civilization of the savages, differ with him as to methods, and hold that the surest, most humane, and least costly method is first of all to secure just treatment to the Indians, as it is not and can not be secured by the present civilian system, and then to prove to them that we have the power to enforce our will, as we do not prove it to them now.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature