Joseph McKenna

“ The contentions of plaintiff in error are based on the treaties and on the 14th Amendment of the Constitution of the United States. The specifications of error are the same, though varying in expression, as those in the Heim Case, and there considered and declared untenable. There is added the view that a distinction made between aliens and citizens violates the principle of classification. ”

“ This case was argued and submitted with No. 386, just decided [ [ [239 U.S. 175] ] , 60 L. ed. --, 36 Sup. Ct. Rep. 78] . It involves the criminal feature of § 14 of the labor law of the state, which was the subject of the opinion in No. ”