Summary

North German Lloyd v. Guaranty Trust Company…

We are wholly unable to accept the argument that although a shipowner may give up his voyage to avoid capture after war is declared, he never is at liberty to anticipate war. In this case the anticipation was correct, and the master is not to be put in the wrong by nice calculations that if all went well he might have delivered the gold and escaped capture by the margin of a few hours. In our opinion the event shows that he acted as a prudent man.
We agree with the counsel for the libellants that on July 27 neither party to the contract thought that it would not be performed.
Source: Wikisource

North German Lloyd v. Guaranty Trust Company…

On July 31 the German Emperor declared a state of war, and the directors of the company at Bremen, knowing that that had been or forthwith would be declared, sent a wireless to the master: 'War has broken out with England, France, and Russia, Return to New York.' Thereupon he turned back. The probability was that the steamship, if not interfered with or prevented by accident or unfavorable weather, would have reached Plymouth between 11 P. M. August 2, and 1 A. M. August 3, and would have delivered the gold destined for England, to be forwarded to London by 6 A. M., August 3.
Source: Wikisource

North German Lloyd v. Guaranty Trust Company…

He had proceeded about as far as he could with coal enough to return if that should prove needful, and was of opinion that the proper course was to turn back. He reached Bar Harbor, Maine, on August 4, avoiding New York on account of supposed danger from British cruisers, and returned the gold to the parties entitled to the same.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature