Summary

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Butchers' Union Slaughter-House Live-Stock Landing Company v…

In this country it has seldom been held, and never in so odious a form as is here claimed, that an entire trade and business could be taken from citizens and vested in a single corporation. Such legislation has been regarded everywhere else as inconsistent with civil liberty. That exists only where every individual has the power to pursue his own happiness according to his own views, unrestrained except by equal, just, and impartial laws.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Butchers' Union Slaughter-House Live-Stock Landing Company v…

It may be that, for the health or safety of a city, the manufacture of beer, or soap, or the smelting of ores, or the casting of machinery should be carried on without its limits, yet it would hardly be contended that the power thus to remove the business beyond certain limits would authorize the granting of a monopoly of it to any one or more persons. And if not a monopoly in business of this character, how can a monopoly for like reasons be granted in the business of preparing animal food for market, or of yarding and sheltering cattle intended for slaughter?
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Stephen Johnson Field Stephen Johnson Field Butchers' Union Slaughter-House Live-Stock Landing Company v…

It is difficult to understand how in a district embracing a population of a quarter of a million, any conditions of health can require that the preparation of animal food should be intrusted to a single corporation for 25 years, or how in a district of such extent there can be only one place in which animals can, with safety to the public health, be sheltered and slaughtered. In the grant of these exclusive privileges a monopoly of an ordinary employment and business was created.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature