Desiré Girouard Canadian opinions on the bill introduced into the Dominion Parliament by Desiré Girouard… (1880)

Does the Levical Law really prohibit marriage with a deceased wife's sister?
Leviticus .xviii. 18 reads: "Neither shalt thou take a wife to her sister to vex her; to uncover her nakedness, beside the other in her lifetime.
The Rev. Dr. Chalmers, no mean authority, gives the tersest and best interpretation of this passage. He says:
"In Leviticus xviii, verse 18, the prohibition is only against marrying the wife's sister during the lifetime of the first wife, which of itself implies the liberty to marry the wife's sister after her death."
Source: Wikisource

Desiré Girouard Canadian opinions on the bill introduced into the Dominion Parliament by Desiré Girouard… (1880)

As to the difference sought to be made between a brother-in-law and sister-in-law, there is none in reason that I can convince—none at least to call for a difference and there is no law, written or unwritten, for it. I say "no law," for the prohibition wherever observed, is one of purely ecclesiastical rule.
Source: Wikisource

Desiré Girouard Canadian opinions on the bill introduced into the Dominion Parliament by Desiré Girouard… (1880)

Dear Sir,—I think that a Catholic can vote for the bill in question, inasmuch as the Catholic Church grants, for grave reasons, a dispensation to marry a deceased wife's sister, &c.
The inconvenience is very serious in the case when a dispensation is granted by the Church and not by the State. The State looks upon, as invalid, a marriage which the Church holds as valid, on account of the dispensation, and the State holds as illegitimate the children, and that they are disqualified to inherit the property of their parents.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature