Summary

Alexander Thomas Emeric Vidal Journal of the Royal Geographical Society of London…

This brief recapitulation of the evidences for the Aitkins' Rock places their discrepancies in a striking point of view; and whether we regard the discordant appearances, or the variety of positions which have been assigned by them, it seems impossible they can refer to one and the same object. It may be added, that, from the experience we have had of the swell on the coast of Ireland, no rock could be so situated without producing very high breakers in bad weather, which would be visible at least two or three miles.
Source: Wikisource

Alexander Thomas Emeric Vidal Journal of the Royal Geographical Society of London…

Fifthly.—An extract from the log-book of the True Briton, James Reid, master, informs us, that on Wednesday, 27th September, 1826, when steering E.S.E., a man at the mast-head called out that there were breakers close to us on the starboard bow. I immediately hauled the brig up, S.S.E., to clear them. In the run of the sea, a rock appeared a little above water, nearly flat, about ninety feet long and forty broad; saw no breakers except round the rock, but could distinctly see the sea working over it.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature