Summary

Portrait of Herbert Spencer Herbert Spencer The Principles of Biology — Appendix C (1898)

Now let us consider the position of those Darwinians who dissent from Darwin, and who make light of all this evidence. We might naturally suppose that their own hypothesis is unassailable. Yet, strange to say, they admit that there is no direct proof that any species has been established by natural selection. The proof is inferential only.
The certainty of an axiom does not give certainty to the deductions drawn from it. That natural selection is, and always has been, operative is incontestable.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Herbert Spencer Herbert Spencer The Principles of Biology — Appendix C (1898)

Development of the musical faculty in the successive members of families from which the great composers have come, as well as in the civilized races at large, is not to be explained by natural selection. Even when it is great, the musical faculty has not a life-saving efficiency as compared with the average of faculties; for the most highly gifted have commonly passed less prosperous lives and left fewer offspring than have those possessed of ordinary abilities.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Herbert Spencer Herbert Spencer The Principles of Biology — Appendix C (1898)

The general argument proceeds upon the analogy between natural selection and artificial selection. Yet all know that the first cannot do what the last does. Natural selection can do nothing more than preserve those of which the aggregate characters are most favourable to life. It cannot pick out those possessed of one particular favourable character, unless this is of extreme importance.
(2) In many cases a structure is of no service until it has reached a certain development
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature