James E. Homans, editor

“ Gilder set an example of enduring and altruistic fidelity. He was an optimist, a poet of distinction, and an editor of exceptional ability. But fine as was the work which he achieved, his manhood challenges admiration from all who are interested in the noblest developments of the human soul. ”

“ During his service on the commission, he arranged to be called whenever there was a fire in a tenement house; and at all hours of the night he risked his health and his life itself to see the perils besetting the dwellers of the tenements, in order to make wise recommendations as to legislation that would minimize these perils. Notwithstanding his gentleness of manner and perfect courtesy, no man could more bravely stand up in civic contests and for the rights of the poor and oppressed. ”

“ Radical and permanent improvements were effected in the housing of the poor in New York, in the opening of small parks in the crowded districts, and in the establishment of playgrounds in connection with the public schools. After the tenement law had been passed, mainly through Gilder's great work, it was well said that “it needed the inspiration and passionate love of the poet to feel the danger to women and children in the tenement houses of New York.” ”