John Weeks Moore, Complete Encyclopaedia of Music… (1880)
“ Most of his songs are likewise extremely energetic and vigorous ; this, in particular, is the characteristic of the two bass songs, "Poised in heaven's eternal scale," and " Thus when young Ammon marched along." As proofs of the beauty and originality of his fancy in ballad composition, every one will admit the charming pastoral melody of "Ye shepherds and nymphs of the grove," the mellifluous and affecting air of "When Damon languished at my feet," the expressive passages in "When beauty on the lover's cheek," and, above all, his popular song of "Kate of Aberdeen." ”
