Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.

Summary

Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. Moyer v. Peabody — Opinion of the Court

If we suppose a governor with a very long term of office, it may be that a case could be imagined in which the length of the imprisonment would raise a different question. But there is nothing in the duration of the plaintiff's detention or in the allegations of the complaint that would warrant submitting the judgment of the governor to revision by a jury. It is not alleged that his judgment was not honest, if that be material, or that the plaintiff was detained after fears of the insurrection were at an end.
Source: Wikisource

Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. Moyer v. Peabody — Opinion of the Court

As no one would deny that there was immunity for ordering a company to fire upon a mob in insurrection, and that a state law authorizing the governor to deprive citizens of life under such circumstances was consistent with the 14th Amendment, we are of opinion that the same is true of a law authorizing by implication what was done in this case.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature