Summary

Portrait of Warren E. Burger Warren E. Burger Chandler v. Judicial Council of the Tenth Circuit…

There can, of course, be no disagreement among us as to the imperative need for total and absolute independence of judges in deciding cases or in any phase of the decisional function. But it is quite another matter to say that each judge in a complex system shall be the absolute ruler of his manner of conducting judicial business. The question is whether Congress can vest in the Judicial Council power to enforce reasonable standards as to when and where court shall be held, how long a case may be delayed in decision, whether a given case is to be tried, and many other routine matters.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Warren E. Burger Warren E. Burger Chandler v. Judicial Council of the Tenth Circuit…

If the challenged action of the Judicial Council was a judicial act or decision by a judicial tribunal, [7] then perhaps it could be reviewed by this Court without doing violence to the constitutional requirement that such review be appellate. As the concurring and dissenting opinions amply demonstrate, finding the prerequisites to support a conclusion that we do have appellate jurisdiction in this case would be no mean feat. It is an exercise we decline to perform since we conclude that in the present posture of the case other avenues of relief on the merits may yet be open to Judge Chandler.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Warren E. Burger Warren E. Burger Chandler v. Judicial Council of the Tenth Circuit…

These questions have long been discussed and debated; they are not easy questions and the risks suggested by the dissents are not to be lightly cast aside. But for the reasons that follow we do not find it necessary to answer them because the threshold question in this case is whether we have jurisdiction to entertain the petition for extraordinary relief.
The authority of this Court to issue a writ of prohibition or mandamus 'can be constitutionally exercised only insofar as such writs are in aid of its appellate jurisdiction.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature