William Bower Taylor, Kinetic Theories of Gravitation… (1876)
“ Guyot believes, he has solved the great problem of energy or dynamic. But it is apparent at a glance that his system is at variance with every feature of the actual phenomenon of gravitation, and fails to represent any of the six conditions-precedent, perhaps excepting the first. If the resultant motion of translation from an acoustic vibration of air (or from a thermal vibration of aether) may be supposed to occur in a right line, it is not established that it can so continue for any considerable distance ”
