Samuel Hubbard Scudder

“ It is rather extraordinary that the upper Miocene beds of Œningen, Bavaria, which, if we except the amber, have furnished almost more insects than all the other beds of fossil insects of the world together, and which are more recent than any of those in which butterflies have been found, have yielded scarcely any remains of Lepidoptera (one species) and none whatever of butterflies. ”

“ Excepting Eurycus and some species of Thais, no modern genera resemble Thaites in the extension of a distinctive pattern upon the hind wings to or nearly to the extremity of the cell. Whether any of the markings were accompanied by the brilliant spots often seen in Thais, Archon and Parnassius cannot be determined, but we may presume that they were not, since in these genera the markings are dark upon a lighter ground, while in Thaites they are light upon a dark ground,—a combination found among the Papilonid genera, only in some of the swallow tails. ”

“ Or, l’étude de cette partie de la [77] ptérologie, qui a pour objet les lois relatives à la position, à la forme, comme à la présence et à l’absence des dessins et des taches, nous apprend que jamais une lunule ou une tache orbiculaire marginale n’est divisée par une nervule, mais plutôt par le pli internervulaire, les nervules séparant d’habitude ces sortes de taches, et ne les scindant pas. ”

“ The fore wing covers the hind wing as in nature, but to such an extent as to conceal the greater part of it; the guttered portion of the inner margin of the hind wings is almost fully expanded, but apparently has a fold next the submedian nervure. The fringe of the fore wing seems to be gone, but that of the hind wing is preserved nearly throughout. Head, fore and middle legs, wings of the right side and abdomen are wholly wanting. ”

“ Based on the distribution of these principal genera alone, the flora of the southern border of Asia would show a closer affinity to that of eocene Aix than would that of any equivalent belt in Africa; and if we may suppose that our relics of butterflies represent the principal genera then existing, we should trace a somewhat similar chart, but for the entire absence of African types; for subtropical American types mingle with those of the Mediterranean district and especially with those of the Indo-Malayan region. ”

“ Ces dessins maculaires peuvent, à la rigueur, y exister, comme n’y pas être, de même qu’ils ne sont guère acceptables à leur autre surface; car ce que nous voyons est bien un dessous d’aile et non un dessus. ”

“ In general, the design of the fore wings approaches that of Neorina Lowii more nearly than that of the upper surface of any other butterfly I have seen, although there is a distant resemblance to the markings of Antirrhæa and Anchiphlebia, as Butler has remarked, as well as toward certain species of Zophoessa. The markings of the upper and under surface of butterflies have nearly always some and often a close relation to each other, and therefore we may reasonably look at the under surface of living insects to find the nearest counterpart to our fossil ”

“ Seated upon the submedian nervure, its centre below the outer edge of the lower median spot, is a pale, powdery spot, twice as long as broad and about one-third the width of the interspace; outwardly it merges into the ground color; there are other pale spaces in the wing, looking somewhat as if due to attrition; especially in the cell on either side of the discoidal spot, at the extreme base of the lower median interspace, and along the lower border of the medio-submedian interspace. ”

“ Thanatites vetula is the only butterfly yet found from this horizon, and this is closely related to Thanaos, a genus belonging to the north temperate zones of both hemispheres, but vastly more developed in the new world, which has at least four times as many species as the old, some of them extending into the subtropical regions. The genera adjacent to Thanaos are purely American, although tropical or subtropical, and therefore the Aquitanian butterfly looks toward subtropical North America for its relatives of the present day. ”

“ The hind wings resemble those of Neorina far more than those of any other genus, but are long and proportionally rather more produced than in Neorina, with less crenation of the outer border, and a shorter and slenderer tail; the costal margin is strongly and abruptly convex next the base, but beyond this passes with a regular and gentle convexity to the outer angle, which is larger than a right angle and somewhat rounded off; above the tail the general trend of the outer border forms scarcely more than a right angle with the general course of the costal margin and is gently crenate ”

“ Its nearest ally among living European types would seem to be Maniola Hermione, in which the costal and median veins are about equally swollen. The neuration of Lethites agrees with this genus in much the same way as it does with Cercyonis, the comparative width of the interspaces beyond the cell being very different in the living genera from what it is in the fossil. In the form of the wing Maniola agrees much better with Lethites than Cercyonis does, but the costa is much more arched, and the cell is much the longer in Maniola ”

“ The food of Pontia Freyeri is doubtful. All the living species of the genus so far as known, feed upon Cruciferæ; within this family they do not seem to be at all particular, making use of a large number of genera, but in only a single instance are they known to attack the leaves of a genus (Reseda) belonging to an adjoining family. Cruciferæ, however, are excessively rare in the tertiaries of Europe, two species only being recorded, and this from the comparatively recent beds of Œningen. ”

“ As our only purpose in this place is to deny the lepidopterous character of Palæontina, it is unnecessary to say anything in defence of the view we have expressed of its homopterous affinities; the superior position of the cell, the position and character of the lower cross veins (which we believe really traversed the entire wing) , with their origin at the indentation of the lower border, suggest such a relationship, although there are not a few points in which it differs somewhat strikingly from living types. ”

“ Analyzing this point still further, we notice that three out of the four species whose living allies are to be sought in the East Indies come from the older deposits of Aix, and that only one of the two remaining Aix species shows special affinities to American types; we thus find here, as among other insects and among the plants, a growing likeness to American types as we pass upward through the European tertiaries. ”

“ We close this portion of our subject with a tabular view of the results we have reached in considering the affinities of the tertiary butterflies with living types, in which the countries, where the living allies of the fossil forms are now found, are placed in the right-hand columns according to the degree of affinity of their inhabitants to the tertiary species against which they are placed. ”

“ As to the flora of Radoboj, Professor Heer writes in the work just quoted (p. 96) : “Les plantes de la zône tempérée sont représentées plus fortement qu’à Sotzka,” and of the latter place he says (p. 95) , after speaking of types of the temperate zone: “Cependant ces espèces se trouvent fort à l’arrière-plan en comparison des formes tropicales et subtropicales, parmi lesquelles prédominent ... les formes indo-australiens; néanmoins les formes américains, loin d’y faire défaut, sont représentées par des types assez nombreux et nettement accusés.” ”

“ Nine well authenticated fossil butterflies are now known, all from the European Tertiaries; five of these have been found in the gypsum beds of Aix in Provence, southern France, belonging to the Ligurian, a division of the upper eocene; one in the lignites of Rott in the Rhenish Provinces of Prussia, belonging to the Aquitanian, or lower miocene; and three in the marls of Radoboj in Croatia, Austria, appertaining to the Mayencian or middle miocene. Our present knowledge, then, places the apparition of butterflies towards the end of the lower tertiaries. ”

“ It is not a little interesting to notice that these authors have arranged this group in immediate proximity to the genus Cyllo (= Melanitis Fabr.) , in which Dr. Boisduval placed the fossil species from Aix, named by him sepulta. Nor is it less interesting to find that in both genera all the living representatives (even including those discovered since the publication of the ‘Genera of Diurnal Lepidoptera’) are natives of the East Indies; so that the fossil butterflies of Provence have their nearest living allies in the far East. ”

“ Two of the more recent species of fossil butterflies are therefore at home where they are found, although the present development of the group of genera to which they belong finds its fullest expression in America; while the third species follows most of those from the lower tertiaries in seeking its allies of to-day in the tropics of the old world. ”

“ The limited number of known fossil butterflies does not give great weight to any general considerations based upon them, but it may at least be worth while to remark that Aix, in Eocene times, had, in the point referred to, an assemblage of plants much better comparable with the East Indian flora of the present day than with the modern European flora, the proportion of known Gramineæ, etc., to the Phanerogamia being five per cent., while the proportion of its grass-feeding butterflies to the other rhopalocerous Lepidoptera is sixty per cent. ”