Summary

Portrait of David Josiah Brewer David Josiah Brewer United States v. Pena — Opinion of the Court

The original petitioners were never put, so far as the record shows, in juridical possession of the entire tract, and such a grant, if it was so intended, was never made effective by any juridical possession. We think it more in consonance with justice and equity to hold, not that the grant was of an entire tract which never became operative because of a failure to give juridical possession, but that the alcalde rightfully understood it as a grant in severalty, and giving juridical possession vested in the grantees the tracts of which they were so placed in possession.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of David Josiah Brewer David Josiah Brewer United States v. Pena — Opinion of the Court

Neither could the alcalde make such a grant. Hays v. United States it may well be doubted whether, since the country was in the possession of the United States forces, and a treaty had already been signed, which was shortly thereafter ratified, for the cession of the entire territory, any Mexican official could by new grants diminish the amount of land which was to become the property of this government. And of course it goes without saying that no such officials had authority under the Constitution and laws of the United States to grant public lands.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of David Josiah Brewer David Josiah Brewer United States v. Pena — Opinion of the Court

The language of the order of the governor seems to contemplate a grant in severalty, for it speaks of 'the general donation, in which shall necessarily be stated the boundaries of said possession.' The outer limits within which the grants are to be made are to be stated, and within those limits the several grantees are to have their possessions. Again, the provisions that 'the alcalde shall take charge of the general document of distribution' and 'give testimonios therefrom as may be requested,' carries the same suggestion.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature