George Gregory Smith, Dictionary of National Biography… (1893)
“ Johnson told Goldsmith that he ‘had talents enough to keep his literary reputation alive as long as he himself lived’ (Boswell, ii. 233) , and he has worked out the same idea in his criticism in the ‘Lives’ (iv. 440) . His lack of originality justified the sorry joke of the aggrieved Theobald, ‘that there is no more conceit in him than in a mallet’ (edit. of Shakespeare, 1733, Pref. lii) ; and Hume's dictum, that ‘he was destitute of the pathetic,’ would not be difficult to prove. ”
