Summary

Portrait of George Shiras, Jr. George Shiras, Jr. Chadwick v. Kelly — Opinion of the Court

It is too late to question the right of the general assembly to establish particular districts for the attainment of special local public good, through works of a particular character, and to order itself, or authorize some political body to order, special assessments to be made, within the district, for the purpose of meeting the cost and expenses of such works.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of George Shiras, Jr. George Shiras, Jr. Chadwick v. Kelly — Opinion of the Court

The brief of the counsel of the plaintiff in error contends that, by the statutes of the state of Louisiana, the property owner is made to pay the cost of the improvement irrespective of the question of benefit, is made personally responsible for the cost of the improvement, although it may largely exceed, not only the benefit to his property, but the value thereof, and his property is made subject to a lien to secure the payment.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of George Shiras, Jr. George Shiras, Jr. Chadwick v. Kelly — Opinion of the Court

With the wisdom or unwisdom of special assessments when ordered in cases in which they are admissible, the courts have no concern, unless there is plainly and manifestly such an abuse of power as takes the case beyond the just limits of legislative discretion.'
No such case is presented by the facts in the present case as would justify an intervention by the Federal courts with a system of special assessments prescribed by the legislature and approved by the courts of a state.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature