Summary

Henry Crozier Keating Plummer On the Theory of Aberration and the Principle of Relativity (1910)

It is easy to see that the old and the new laws of aberration agree to the first order of small quantities. Beyond the first order, the present accuracy of astronomical observations does not encourage us to look for any means of discriminating between them. Nevertheless it is interesting to ask whether the principle of relativity, as outlined above, has robbed us of the theoretical possibility of detecting the effect of the motion of the solar system through the ether of space.
Source: Wikisource

Henry Crozier Keating Plummer On the Theory of Aberration and the Principle of Relativity (1910)

If we have reason to be dissatisfied with the results of the efforts hitherto made to determine the constant of aberration, we have little ground for taking into account the second-order effects. But on the other hand an optical experiment has been performed which cannot be reconciled with the ordinary theory, and we have been forced to admit that the theory, if not actually erroneous, can be no more than an approximation to the truth.
Source: Wikisource

Henry Crozier Keating Plummer On the Theory of Aberration and the Principle of Relativity (1910)

Hence actual configurations on the sphere are only changed conformally by the effect of aberration, or in other words any small area is altered only in size and not in shape. We know that aberration merely changes the scale of a photograph of a small part of the sky, and the truth of this fact now becomes independent of the velocity (however large) of the observer. Also stars which appear to lie on a circle at any one time will continue to do so permanently.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature