Summary

Portrait of Samuel Freeman Miller Samuel Freeman Miller National Bank of Washington v. Texas…

It was the duty of the cashier to inquire at the Treasury Department. He did so, and learned that there was no objection to any of the bonds but those which had been delivered to White and Chiles, and he became satisfied that those involved in this controversy did not belong to that class. It was impossible for him to find and consult all those through whose hands they might have passed before they were offered to the bank.
If negotiable paper, underdue, be in the hands of a bon a fide holder, any subsequent holder may avail himself of that fact against the equity of the maker.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Samuel Freeman Miller Samuel Freeman Miller National Bank of Washington v. Texas…

The former was examined at much length, and gave it as his opinion, from certain calculations made by him, based upon papers in his office and information received by him from officers of the State of Texas, and other sources, that these bonds were of the White and Chiles issue. He says that it is only an opinion, and it is evident from his deposition that the data on which he bases that opinion are far from conclusive. It is not worth while to waste words in proving that such testimony is wholly incompetent to establish any fact, or rather to show that it is not evidence at all.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Samuel Freeman Miller Samuel Freeman Miller National Bank of Washington v. Texas…

Every holder is presumed to have acquired his title before the maturity of the instrument and bon a fide. The burden of proof rests upon the party alleging the contrary. [15] It is only in case of dishonor that the equities of the maker, or obligor, can be set up against a bon a fide holder. It may be doubted whether these bonds belonged to that class. [16] I have preferred to consider the case in this aspect, upon the hypothesis most favorable to the complainant.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature