Summary

Constitutional Court of South Africa Du Toit and Another v Minister of Welfare and Population Development and Others (2002)

I am of the view that such a remedy serves to protect not only the applicants’ equal parenting rights in respect of the siblings, but all permanent same-sex life partners wanting to adopt children jointly or to undertake joint guardianship.
[43] ⁠I should, however, emphasise that in each decision concerning adoption, prospective adoptive parents should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis as provided for in the Child Care Act. In so doing, care will be taken to ensure that only suitable couples will be entitled to adopt children jointly.
Source: Wikisource

Constitutional Court of South Africa Du Toit and Another v Minister of Welfare and Population Development and Others (2002)

However, our Constitution requires that unfairly discriminatory treatment of such relationships cease. It is significant that there have been a number of recent cases, [32] statutes [33] and government consultation documents [34] in South Africa which broaden the scope of concepts such as “family”, “spouse” and “domestic relationship”, to include same-sex life partners. These legislative and jurisprudential developments indicate the growing recognition afforded to same-sex relationships.
Source: Wikisource

Constitutional Court of South Africa Du Toit and Another v Minister of Welfare and Population Development and Others (2002)

The unfair effect of the discrimination is squarely founded on an intersection of the grounds upon which the applicants’ complaint is based: [26] the applicants’ status as unmarried persons which currently precludes them from joint adoption of the siblings is inextricably linked to their sexual orientation. But for their sexual orientation which precludes them from entering into a marriage, they fulfil the criteria that would otherwise make them eligible jointly to adopt children in terms of the impugned legislation.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature