Summary

Portrait of Howell Edmunds Jackson Howell Edmunds Jackson Hardenbergh v. Ray — Opinion of the Court

In respect to the question of testamentary power of disposition over real estate, the Missouri act adopted by the territorial government, and re-enacted by the state of Oregon, was unquestionably intended to be as broad and comprehensive as the Virginia act of 1785, which conferred the testamentary power to devise after-acquired land, and was more comprehensive than the prior act of 1844, taken from the Iowa statute. As already stated, the language of the statute makes no distinction between personalty and realty. It confers the power to dispose of the realty as broadly as the personalty.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Howell Edmunds Jackson Howell Edmunds Jackson Hardenbergh v. Ray — Opinion of the Court

We think not. The language now used does not required such a construction at our hands. It is different from the English statute of wills. The testamentary power is given here in general language. It embraces both real and personal property, and is a power to make testamentary disposition of all the testator's property, without any distinction between real and personal property, and not a mere power of particular disposition. It is more in the nature of a Roman will than an English devise of real property.
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Howell Edmunds Jackson Howell Edmunds Jackson Hardenbergh v. Ray — Opinion of the Court

The reason given for the distinction between real and personal estate was that a devise of land was regarded in the same light as a conveyance, and, as a conveyance at common law would not vest for want of seisin, it was therefore held to be operative only on such real estate as the testator might have at the time of the making of the will,-that is to say, that a devise was in the nature of a conveyance or appointment of real estate then owned, to take effect at a future date, and could not, therefore, operate on future acquisitions.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature