Pataliputra

Definition and stakes

Joseph David Freedone Melik Beglar,  Report of a Tour through the Bengal Provinces (1878)

“ It is hardly possible that all traces of the grandeur of the city should have so completely disappeared, if the city stood where modern Patna now stands; but if the Ganges has swallowed it, the complete disappearance is accounted for.
Greek writers mention that the walls of Palibothra were of wood. It most probably was so then, but the clear evidence of Fa Hian and of the Mudra Râkshasa shows that Pâṭaliputra was not a wooden city in their time.
”
Source: Wikisource

W. W. W. Humbley,  Journal of a Cavalry Officer; Including the Memorable Sikh Campaign of 1845-1846

“ Now it is very certain that the Sone, lacking this sacred character, could not have been reckoned as the third river in India; superior to many streams which take their rise from the Himalaya, and inferior only to the Ganges and the Indus, both of which are regarded with the deepest reverence.
Thus, with regard to Patna, we are led to the conclusion, that, while there is great evidence to prove that it is a most ancient city, and to identify it with the former Pataliputra, the capital of the Gupta dynasty; yet it is quite as clear that it is not the site of Palibothra.
”
Source: Gutenberg

W. W. W. Humbley,  Journal of a Cavalry Officer; Including the Memorable Sikh Campaign of 1845-1846

“ Now, though the ancient kingdom of Maghada included Patna, it is not probable that there was a capital so low down. Heeren [Pg 313] declares that the empire of the Prasii extended beyond the junction of the Jumna with the Ganges, and we may infer from this that the said junction was not much short of the limits of the empire. And, speaking of particular towns, he names Ayodhya, Kanoge, and others. Also mentioning Pataliputra (Patna) the same author says: "The scene of these fables (Hitopadesah, or Pilpay) is laid in the city of Pataliputra, by no means the most ancient in India." ”
Source: Gutenberg

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature