A. C. Seward

“ While always on the alert for rational explanations of obscure phenomena by means of the analogy supplied by existing causes, and ready to draw from a wide knowledge of recent botany, in the interpretation of problems furnished by fossil plants, the palaeobotanist must be constantly alive to the necessity for cautious statement. That there is the greatest need of moderation and safe reasoning in dealing with the botanical problems of past ages, will be apparent to anyone possessing but a superficial acquaintance with fossil plant literature. ”

“ Primarily concerned, therefore, with fixing the age of strata, it is easy to understand how geologists have been content with a special kind of palaeontology which is out of touch with the methods of systematic zoology or botany. On the other hand, the botanist whose observations and researches have not extended beyond the limits of existing plants, sees in the vast majority of fossil forms merely imperfect specimens, which it is impossible to determine with any degree of scientific accuracy. He prefers to wait for perfect material ”

“ The distribution of fossil plants lies at the foundation of the principles of the present grouping of floras on the Earth’s surface. Those who have confined their study of distribution to the plant geography of the present age, must supplement their investigations by reference to the work of palaeobotanical writers. If the lists of plant species drawn up by specialists in fossil botany, have been prepared with a due sense of the important conclusions which botanists may draw from them from the standpoint of distribution, they will be readily accepted as sound links in the chain of evidence. ”

“ There is no golden rule, and we must admit the difficulty of separating real fossil algae from markings made by animal or mechanical agency. The presence of a carbonaceous film is occasionally a help, but its occurrence is no sure test of plant origin, nor is its absence a fatal objection to an organic origin. While being fully alive to the small value of external resemblance, and to the numerous agents which have been shown to be capable of producing appearances indistinguishable from plant impressions, we must not go too far in a purely negative direction. ”

“ The earliest representatives of organic life were doubtless of such a perishable nature that their remains could not be preserved in a fossil state even under the most favourable conditions. Such organisms, whether plants or animals, as possessed any resistant tissues or hard skeletons might be preserved in the oldest rocks, but as these strata became involved in earth-foldings or were penetrated by injections of igneous eruptions, the relics of life would be entirely destroyed. ”

“ Since the greater refinements and thoroughness of scientific methods and the enormous and ever-increasing mass of literature have inevitably led to extreme specialisation, it is more than ever important to look beyond the immediate limits of one’s own subject, and to note its points of contact with other lines of research. A palaeobotanist is primarily concerned with the determination and description of fossil plants, but he must at the same time constantly keep in view the bearing of his work on wider questions of botanical or geological importance. ”

“ FOSSIL PLANTS AND PHYLOGENY.
Not only is it possible to derive valuable aid in the correlation of strata from the facts of plant distribution, but we may often follow the various stages in the history of a particular genus as we trace the records of its occurrence through the geologic series. In studying the march of plant life through past ages, the botanist may sometimes follow the progress of a genus from its first appearance, through the time of maximum development, to its decline or extinction. ”

“ It has been clearly demonstrated that in Lyginodendron, we have anatomical peculiarities typical of recent cycads, combined with structural characteristics always associated with existing ferns. In rare cases, it happens that the remarkably perfect fossilisation of the tissues of fossil plants, enables us not only to give a complete description of the histology of extinct forms, but also to speak with confidence as to some of those physiological processes which governed their life. ”

“ To measure, and name such bodies as definite species of Micrococci is, I believe, but wasted energy and an attempt to compass the impossible.
Specialists tell us that the accurate determination of species of recent Bacteria is practically hopeless: may we not reasonably conclude that the attempt to specifically diagnose fossil forms is absolutely hopeless? “The imagination of man is naturally sublime, delighted with whatever is remote and extraordinary—”, but it is to be deplored if the fascination of fossil bacteriology is allowed to warp sound scientific sense. ”

“ The first formed rocks no doubt became at once the prey of denudation and disintegration, and on their surface would be accumulated the products of their own destruction: newer strata would entirely cover up portions of the original land, to be in their turn succeeded by still later deposits. There is reason to believe that in the remotest ages of the Earth’s history, the forces of denudation and igneous activity were more potent than in later times, and thus the oldest rocks could hardly retain their original structure through the long ages of geologic time. ”

“ If special attention were paid to the investigation of fossil fungi, it is quite possible that our knowledge of the past history of the group might be considerably extended. It is essential that the greatest caution should be exercised in the identification of forms and in their reference to definite families; otherwise our lists of fossil species will serve to mislead, and to emphasize the untrustworthy character of palaeobotanical data. Unless we feel satisfied as to the position of a fossil fungus it is unwise to use a generic term suggestive of a definite family or recent genus. ”

“ The term ‘fossil’ suggests to the lay mind a petrifaction or a replacement by mineral matter of the plant tissues. In the scientific sense, a fossil plant, that is a plant or part of a plant whether in the form of a true petrifaction or a structureless mould or cast, which has been buried in the earth by natural causes, may be indistinguishable from a piece of recent wood lately fallen from the parent tree. ”

“ The opportunities for criticism in matters relating to nomenclature are particularly numerous, and the critic who may be but imperfectly familiar with the subject-matter of a scientific work is not slow to avail himself of some supposed eccentricity on the part of the author in the manner of terminology. The true value of work may be obscured by laying too much emphasis on the imperfections of a somewhat heterodox nomenclature. On the other hand good systematic work is often seriously spoilt by a want of attention to generally accepted rules in naming and defining species. ”

“ Passing from the nature and mode of origin of the sedimentary strata to the manner of their arrangement in the Earth’s crust, we must endeavour to sketch in the merest outline the methods of stratigraphical geology. The surface of the Earth in some places stands out in the form of bare masses of rock, roughly hewn or finely carved by Nature’s tools of frost, rain or running water ”

“ It is not merely the commoner and more familiar recent genera with which the student of extinct types must be acquainted, but it is extremely important 243that he should make himself familiar with the rarer, less known and more isolated recent forms, which often throw most light on the affinities of the older representatives of the group. It is often the case, the more isolated living plants are, the more likely are they to afford valuable assistance in the interpretation of genera representing a class, which reached its maximum development in the earlier periods of the earth’s history. ”

“ With the exception of the algae and a few representatives of other classes of plants, which live in the shallow-water belt round the coast, or in inland lakes and seas, plants are confined to land-surfaces; and unless their remains are swept along by streams and embedded in sediments which are accumulating on the sea floor, the chance of their preservation is but small. The strata richest in fossil plants are often those which have been laid down on the floor of an inland lake or spread out as river-borne sediment under the waters of an estuary. ”

“ One of the most striking facts to be gleaned from a general survey of the past history of the Equisetaceae is the persistence since the latter part of the Palaeozoic period of that type of plant which is represented by existing Equisetums. There is perhaps no genus in existence which illustrates more vividly than Equisetum the survival of an extremely ancient group, which is represented to-day by numerous and widely spread species. ”

“ The mineralisation of the most delicate tissues and the preservation of the various forms of cell-contents are now generally admitted by those at all conversant with the possibilities of plant petrifaction. If we consider what these facts mean—the microscopic investigation of not only the finest framework but even the very life-substance of Palaeozoic plants—we feel that the aeons since the days when these plants lived have been well-nigh obliterated. ”

“ In the early part of the present century, and still more in the eighteenth century, the occurrence of fossil plants and animals in the earth’s crust formed the subject of animated, not to say acrimonious, discussion. The result was that many striking and ingenious theories were formulated as to the exact manner of formation of fossil remains, and the part played by the waters of the deluge in depositing fossiliferous strata. The earlier views on fossil vegetables are naturally bound up with the gradual evolution of geological science. ”

“ If we look back through a few decades, and peruse the pages of Lindley and Hutton’s classic work [36] on the Fossil flora of Great Britain, a book which is indispensable to fossil botanists, and read the description of such a genus as Sigillaria or Stigmaria; or if we extend our retrospect to an earlier period and read Woodward’s description of an unusually good specimen of a Lepidodendron, and finally take stock of our present knowledge of such plants, we realise what enormous progress has been made in palaeobotanical studies. ”

“ Around the coast-line of land areas, and on the floor of shallow seas algae exhibit a remarkable wealth of form and luxuriance of growth. As regards habit and structure, there is every gradation from algae in which the whole individual consists of a thin-walled unseptate vesicle, to those in which the thallus attains a length unsurpassed by any other plant, and of which the anatomical features clearly express a well-marked physiological division of labour such as occurs in the highest plants. ”

“ Seeing how very few fossil forms have been described which have any claim to inclusion in this subdivision of the Algae, it is unnecessary to enumerate or define the various families of the Chlorophyceae. It is true that many species have been figured as examples of different genera of green algae, but few of these possess any scientific value. There is, however, one division of the Chlorophyceae, the Siphoneae, which must be treated at some length on account of its importance from a palaeobotanical and geological point of view. ”

“ If we possessed complete records of the Earth’s history, we should have an unbroken sequence, not merely of the various forms of life that ever existed, but of the different kinds of rocks formed in the successive ages of past time. As gaps exist in the chain of life, so also do we find considerable breaks in the sequence of strata which have been formed since the beginning of geologic time. The danger as well as the convenience of artificial classification must be kept in view. ”

“ More trustworthy evidence of fossil fungi is afforded by the marks of disease in petrified tissue and by the presence of true mycelia. In examining closely the calcareous and siliceous plant-tissues from the Coal-Measures and other geological horizons, one occasionally sees fine thread-like hyphae ramifying through the cells or tracheal cavities; in many cases the hyphae bear no reproductive organs and cannot as a rule be referred to a particular type of fungus. If the hyphal filaments are unseptate, they most likely belong to some Phycomycetous species ”

“ Even in plants in which the woody stems have been preserved by a siliceous or calcareous solution, we frequently find the more delicate cells represented by a mass of crystalline matter without any trace of the cell-walls being preserved. In such plants as algae, where the cell-walls are not lignified, but consist of cellulose or some special form of cellulose, which readily breaks down into a mucilaginous product, the tissues have but a small chance of withstanding the wear and tear of fossilisation. ”

“ Although our exact knowledge of fossil Cyanophyceae is extremely small, it is probable that such simple forms of plants existed in abundance during the past ages in the earth’s history. Several writers have expressed the opinion that the blue-green algae may be taken as the modern representatives of those earliest plants which first existed on an archaean land-surface. The living species possess the power of resisting unfavourable conditions in a marked degree, and are able to adapt themselves to very different surroundings. ”

“ It is impossible to follow in the case of all fossil species precisely the same treatment as with the more complete and perfect recent plants; but it is of the utmost importance for a student of palaeobotany, by adhering to the methods of recent botany, to preserve as far as he is able the continuity of the past and present floras. ”