Patrick Weston Joyce

Patrick Weston Joyce

Summary

Portrait of Patrick Weston Joyce Patrick Weston Joyce English as we speak it in Ireland… (1910)

In many parts of Ireland they are shy of using shall at all: I know this to be the case in Munster; and a correspondent informs me that shall is hardly ever heard in Derry.
The incorrect use of will in questions in the first person singular ('Will I light the fire ma'am?' 'Will I sing you a song?'—instead of 'Shall I?') appears to have been developed in Ireland independently, and not derived from any former correct usage: in other words we have created this incorrect locution—or vulgarism—for ourselves. It is one of our most general and most characteristic speech errors.
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature