William Rosecrans

Definition and stakes

William Franklin Gore Shanks,  Personal Recollections of Distinguished Generals

“ I have known him, when merely directing an orderly to carry a dispatch from one point to another, grow so excited, vehement, and incoherent as to utterly confound the messenger. In great danger as in small [Pg 261] things, this nervousness incapacitated him from the intelligible direction of his officers or effective execution of his plans. He possessed no control over himself, and consequently was not capable of directing others.
WILLIAM S. ROSECRANS.
Rosecrans was not an impressive man. It was too apparent that all he did was for "effect," in the theatrical sense.
”
Source: Gutenberg

William Franklin Gore Shanks,  Personal Recollections of Distinguished Generals

“ He did not "wear well" even with the troops, who are the last of an army to give up their worship of a general. He was not long admired by his subordinate officers, and, though a great favorite with his soldiers, they never lavished upon him that intense devotion which they felt for Thomas, and which seldom found utterance in noisy demonstration. Rosecrans had a system by which to gain the affections of his men totally different from that of Thomas or Grant. It was, however, the false system of the demagogue. He never passed a regiment without having a pleasant word for the men. ”
Source: Gutenberg

William Franklin Gore Shanks,  Personal Recollections of Distinguished Generals

“ The people of the East, naturally absorbed in the interests which are nearest and dearest to them, are intimately acquainted with the history and achievements of the chosen leaders of their sons and brothers of the Potomac armies, but know little in detail of the leaders of the Western armies. To the people of the East, Rosecrans is a myth of whom they remember only that he met disaster at Chickamauga; and of Thomas they know little more than that he was the hero of that same defeat. ”
Source: Gutenberg

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature