Shinar

Definition and stakes

Portrait of A. H. Sayce A. H. Sayce,  Patriarchal Palestine

“ Unless Sumer and Shinar are the same words, outside the Old Testament there is only one Shinar known to ancient geography. That was in Mesopotamia. The Greek geographers called it Singara (now Sinjar) , an oasis in the midst of deserts, and formed by an isolated mountain tract abounding in springs. It is already mentioned in the annals of the Egyptian conqueror Thothmes III. In his thirty-third year (B.C. 1470) , the king of Sangar sent him tribute consisting of lapis-lazuli "of Babylon," and of various objects carved out of it. ”
Source: Gutenberg

Portrait of Franz Delitzsch Franz Delitzsch,  Biblical Commentary Old Testament… (1884)

“ In this the woman of sin is brought to rest. The land in which the woman of sin carried away out of the holy land is permanently to dwell, is the land of Shinar. This name is not to be identified with Babel, so as to support the conclusion that it refers to a fresh removal of the people of Israel into exile; but according to Gen 10:10 and Gen 11:2, Shinar is the land in which Nimrod founded the first empire, and where the human race built the tower of Babel which was to reach to the sky. ”
Source: Wikisource

Zénaïde A. Ragozin,  Chaldea: From the Earliest Times to the Rise of Assyria

“ The people of Shumir and Accad, therefore, were one and the same Turanian nation, the difference in the name [Pg 146] being merely a geographical one. Shumir is Southern or Lower Chaldea, the country towards and around the Persian Gulf,—that very land of Shinar which is mentioned in Genesis xi. 2. Indeed "Shinar" is only the way in which the Hebrews pronounced and spelt the ancient name of Lower Chaldea. Accad is Northern or Upper Chaldea. The most correct way, and the safest from all misunderstanding, is to name the people the Shumiro-Accads and their language, the Shumiro-Accadian ”
Source: Gutenberg

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature