H. G. Seeley

“ The wide throat and the weak and high supports of the jaw-bone make it probable that they only used their teeth to capture their prey and not to mince it. By means of their long neck, which they usually bore curved backward in order to keep their balance, they could stretch out their head to their prey and change their centre of gravity, and so fly in different positions. The fundamental type of the Crocodile and Monitor leads us to suspect that they had a skin covered with scales. The approximation to the shape of the Bird makes it probable that they were feathered. ”

“ Walker generously gave me permission to remove the investing cancellous bone and phosphate of lime, and thus exhibit the form of the cerebrum and its relations to the cerebellum. The lower part of the brain is not preserved. But adherent to the sides of the fossil are still left parts of the temporal bones, and part of the bone at the back of the orbit which closes in the brain. ”

“ The inferior outline is concave from front to back, sometimes narrower, sometimes broader than the upper part of the bone, while the inferior aspect is always more flattened than the superior aspect. On each side on the lower half of the bone is a deep groove. The articular end is divided into an upper articular part, which extends as far down as the lateral groove and a lower non-articular part with ligament markings. The articulation is concave from above downward, and is divided into two lateral parts by a mesial vertical ridge. The articular end is about half as deep as the bone is long. ”

“ The hind-foot is much too small for such an upright position, and the fore-foot much too strongly developed. I therefore believe that the Pterodactyle could much better have walked four-footed than a bat, because it possessed so much better developed fore-feet.' In the length of the tibia Burmeister sees no reason for the upright position, but, as he says, only a means for the wide expansion of the flying-membrane;—and an endeavour in walking on four feet to bring the leg into the necessary harmony with the arm, which is so much elongated with the flat-hand. ”

“ They are all simple, conical, and nearly alike, as in the crocodiles, monitors, and other lizards." But, on the one hand, the Dolphins demonstrate that a mammal might have similar teeth even in the maxillary bone; and, on the other hand, since teeth in the premaxillary bone always are single-fanged, and commonly have a simple sub-conical crown, there is absolutely no evidence in the teeth of the affinities of the animal, which, so far as this portion of its economy went, might as well have been a fish or a mammal as anything else. ”

“ The neural spine is high, compressed so as to have the lateral surfaces sub-parallel and rounding into each other superiorly; and it has a less antero-posterior extent than the centrum. At its base behind it widens rapidly, and forms massive quadrate processes, extending outward and backward, which on the outside each have a flattened ovate zygapophysial facet, which also looks downward. Above the facet and separated from it by a groove is a tubercle. Between the zygapophyses behind the bone is concave from side to side; the facets are placed above the neural canal. ”

“ The shoulder-blade of the reptile, with its extremities forming the glenoid cavity, is necessarily smaller and prolonged backward, and altered to resemble that of a bird. The scapula only formed the back part of the glenoid cavity, but it is thick and strong, suggesting an affinity with the bats.
The breast-bone, in the form of a shield, is changing into that of a bird; as are the ribs, which are attached in a peculiar way to the vertebral column. It is really the strong sternum of the Chameleon, with moveable dorsal vertebræ. ”

“ But no Pterodactyle has the head of the humerus convex from the radial to the ulnar sides, and the bird is distinctive in having the ulnar crest developed on the inferior side of the head: a faint approximation to a similar development is seen in Crocodile, but there is no trace of such a process in Pterodactyle. The distal end is more Bird-like than Lacertian in form, but is twisted to a greater angle with the proximal end than in birds.
Altogether the bone is distinctive. The points in which it is unlike birds and reptiles are those in which Birds and Lizards resemble each other ”

“ For I imagine, if it can be determined what the nervous and respiratory and circulatory structures of the Pterodactyle were, it becomes a secondary matter to know whether the phalanges are like a lizard's, or the pelvis like that of a mammal. If the animal is asserted to be a mammal, a reptile, or a bird, we ought to be able to adduce evidence that it had the soft parts which are deemed distinctive of the selected class. ”

“ The articular surface appears to have an elongated sub-reniform shape, the part at the compressed side of the bone being narrower than the broad ovate part on the thick side of the bone, to the lateral limit of which it extends, while the narrow part does not extend laterally nearly so far as the inflected border, which appears to give attachment to powerful muscles. There is also a strong muscular attachment at the corresponding diagonal corner of the bone where the outer surface on its right meets the side of the bone in an elevated ridge. ”

“ And before a naturalist can say, since an animal has for instance a tail like a mammal that in so far it must be affiliated to the mammalia, he must have determined why the mammalian tail has its peculiar characters, and whether it is compatible with any other common plan of organization. ”

“ Among mammals a straight elongated narrow scapula is rare. The mole however has a scapula of this kind somewhat cylindrical in its proximal half and not much expanded at the free end, on which there is a small spine. The anterior emargination above the glenoid cavity in Pterodactyle is entirely mammalian, as is the anterior tuberosity above the emargination, for it entirely corresponds with what in ruminants, pachyderms and many mammals would be named the coracoid process. ”

“ In length the metacarpus resembles that of the Ruminants, in which however it consists of but one bone; while in Pterodactyles there is a separate bone for each of the four fingers; they are closely united together without being blended. In some Pterodactyles the metacarpals of the short fingers are as fine as hairs, so that it is impossible that they should have articular facets on the carpus. In Ornithopterus the metacarpus has some resemblance with that of the bird, but the articulation with the phalanges of the finger for flight is stiff. ”

“ In no living Reptile is there a scapula to be compared with that of the Pterodactyle, for besides the free end being expanded, in the crocodile, it is also thin and squamous and the bone makes a continuous curve with the coracoid as in struthious birds, and not a sharp angle as in Pterodactyles. ”

“ The bone is at the proximal end straight and sub-cylindrical, slowly enlarging proximally; convex behind, except for an elevated boss some little way below the proximal articulation for the attachment of powerful muscles. In front the shaft is a little flattened proximally, with a mesial groove dividing two prominences which are apparently homologous with the ridges below the patella in birds. The proximal articular surface truncates the shaft at right angles except at what is regarded as the outer front aspect, where it rises into a small patelloid prominence. ”

“ The hind-leg is, in proportion to the fore-leg, weak, and in general does not take the bird-form, but that of a Saurian. It has five toes, with unusual arrangement of the phalanges into the series 1, 5, 4, 3, 2. One toe has no nail, and the others have claws weaker than those of the hand. It can hardly be supposed that the animal lived in the water. All Saurians that live either in the water or on land are short-legged; it is the same with the swimming birds. But the Pterodactyle has its hind-legs as long as a land or air-bird ”

“ The creatures have wings; and no reptile known, from recent or fossil specimens, has wings. The general plan of the wing, though very unlike, approximates to that of a bird. Most birds have two phalanges in the long finger, though some have three. One Pterodactyle is described as having only two phalanges in the wing-finger, while most of the German specimens appear to have four phalanges. In birds the longest finger appears to be the middle one, while in Pterodactyles it is the innermost one. ”

“ The Ornithosaurian humerus has but little in common with that of any mammal. Most mammals have the proximal head of the bone hemispherical, and a pit at the distal end for the olecranon process of the ulna, while there is usually little indication of a radial crest, and the proximal and distal ends are in the same plane. In the Bat however the bone is twisted a little so that the slight radial crest looks in the same direction as the distal end, here also there is no pit for the olecranon ”

“ In the succession there is nothing very distinctive. In the Crocodile one tooth comes up under another, as is commonly the case with mammals; and in mammals the fangs of the old teeth are often partially absorbed so that the teeth drop out into the mouth. In the Pterodactyle the new teeth came up on the inner side, as in the Ichthyosauria—a tribe of animals as singular in their affinities as the Ornithosauria. ”