William Alexander Greenhill,
Dictionary of National Biography…
(1892)
“ In 1809 he published his ‘Outlines of Mineralogy’ (2 vols. 8vo, Oxford) , which were reviewed by Dr. Thomas Thomson of Edinburgh in the ‘Quarterly Review’ (vol. ii.) in an article which Gifford, the editor, altered in some parts as being ‘very splenetic and very severe, and much too wantonly so.’ Gifford added: ‘Kidd is a modest and unassuming man, and is not to be attacked with sticks and stones like a savage’ (Smiles, Memoir of John Murray, i. 162) . ”
