Jules Janin

Definition and stakes

Various,  The Atlantic Monthly (1864)

“ Monsieur Jules Janin is, notwithstanding all this, an excellent fellow, and a man of great talents; but you must not ask him to work miracles; in other words, you must not ask him to express briefly and clearly what he thinks of the play he criticizes, nor to remember to-day the opinion he entertained yesterday. These are miracles he cannot work. He hears a piece; he is delighted with it; he says to the author, 'Your piece is charming. You will be gratified by my criticism upon it.' He comes home; he sits at his desk. What happens? Why, the wind which blew from the north blows from the south ”
Source: Wikisource

Harry A. Spurr,  The Life and Writings of Alexandre Dumas (1902)

“ If he has shown us humanity more generous than it is, do not reproach him for that: he has painted it in his own image." "Old folk blessed him," wrote Jules Janin, "for he made easy the path to the grave; the women called upon him to aid them against their sadness, and the young men swore by the romances of their poet." "All our hospital patients recover or die with one of your father's books under their pillow," said a surgeon to Alexandre Dumas fils. ”
Source: Wikisource

Anne Homan-Mulock Kennard,  Rachel (1894)

“ But is it right that eternal oblivion should be the lot of those who have been the delight of their age and country? Ought we not to talk of them, and try as far as we can to keep their memory alive in the hearts of the generation that revelled in their genius, and the generation that only knows them by hearsay?
Jules Janin endeavours repeatedly, in his life of Rachel, to deprive Samson of all the honour and credit of having trained and cultivated her undeveloped talent.
”
Source: Wikisource

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature