Journal article

Definition and stakes

Portrait of Henry Richard Tedder Henry Richard Tedder,  1911 Encyclopædia Britannica (1911)

“ In modern times the weekly journal has become so much of the nature of a newspaper that it seldom can be called a periodical in this sense. The present article chiefly deals with publications devoted to general literature, literary and critical reviews and magazines for the supply of miscellaneous reading. In the article Societies (q.v.) an account is separately given of the transactions and proceedings of learned and scientific bodies, Year-books, almanacs, directories and other annuals belong to a distinct type of publication, and are not referred to here. ”
Source: Wikisource

Portrait of Charles A. Cutter Charles A. Cutter,  Rules for a Dictionary Catalogue

“ There are, however, some “Journals” published by or “under the auspices of” societies which are really periodicals, and should be so treated in entry, the society being not the author but the editor. Again, there are works which occupy a borderland between the two classes, in regard to which the puzzled cataloguer should remember that it is not of much importance which way he decides, provided he is careful to make all necessary references. Examples of such doubtful cases are “Alpine journal: a record of mountain adventure and scientific observation. ”
Source: Gutenberg

Get perspective with Kwize: daily news enlightened by great literature